Home About Games Forum Links   Contact

UdderPunch Forum : Comments & Ratings

Current User: Guest Login Register
Please consider registering

Search 
Search Forums:


 




Comments & Ratings

UserPost

1:44 pm
December 13, 2007


kofman

Green Horn

posts 14

1

I think a commenting and maybe a rating system would be a nice feature for the games in Udder Punch.

8:02 pm
December 14, 2007


DrRetard

Moderator

posts 18

2

Well… I see two sides, it would be nice to find the best of the best, but it would be kindof harsh to see a game you worked really hard on rated as a one out of five.

 I dont have a solid vote, but I do lean towards the rating system.

8:20 pm
December 14, 2007


Booker

Admin

posts 15

3

Hmmmmm.  This is something I’ve never thought about.  I don’t know.  I would really rather not have people flaming other peoples work on this site.  Something tells me, that most people wouldn’t give an honest review.  Most people would either bash the game cause they don’t like the people who made it (or as a joke) or they would vote it high even though the game doesn’t deserve it becuase they wanted to be nice.  If enough people log on and say they want it, I will consider it.

9:12 pm
December 14, 2007


tstyron

Green Horn

posts 10

4

Seems like a decent idea, but the chances of there even being any remotely accurate reviews is slim to none. That and if you knew the coders there is probably going to be some bias one way or the other (Kofman’s SGD Balls game deserves five stars or whatever; that collision logic is fucking wicked retarded).

9:27 pm
December 15, 2007


DrRetard

Moderator

posts 18

5

tstyron said:

(Kofman’s SGD Balls game deserves five stars or whatever; that collision logic is fucking wicked retarded).

 


There should be a section on this site for such things. Im sure some people would willingly submit a game they worked hard on & failed to accomplish, giving an example to future students.

 

Kofman’s idea was good but I bet it was a bitch to program under a deadline.

11:42 pm
December 15, 2007


tstyron

Green Horn

posts 10

6

I only know about his collision because I helped him with it one morning. Made me almost cry. ; ;

7:26 am
December 18, 2007


kofman

Green Horn

posts 14

7

Thanks, I actually finished all the logic in that game by deadline, features, game modes, and the like well that’s another story but the core gameplay did get finished and I have to say that things did get a lot harder past the collision. The recursive traversal was a bit of a pain once bugs started showing up. I’m sure I’ll get to use the same techniques in other games, so w/e it was a pretty good learning experience.

1:55 pm
January 9, 2008


thursday609

Green Horn

posts 1

8

there should be a counter for how many times each game was d/led

2:13 pm
January 9, 2008


DrRetard

Moderator

posts 18

9

People could tilt the downloads on purpose, I enjoy the ambiguity of the site because you never know what your going to get. On the other hand counters might help someone find some form of inspiration or entertainment.

 

12:11 pm
January 26, 2008


Booker

Admin

posts 15

10

Hmmm counters is an idea.  If more of you guys think it’s a good idea, let me know.  I’ll see if it’s possible.



Reply to Topic: Comments & Ratings

NOTE: New Posts are subject to administrator approval before being displayed

Guest Name (Required):

Guest EMail (Required):

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of: 4 + 7        (Required)

Topic Reply:


 

About the UdderPunch forum

Currently Online:

1 Guest

Maximum Online: 23

Forums:

Groups: 1

Forums: 5

Topics: 21

Posts: 75

Members:

There are 28 members

There are 1 guests


Booker has made 15 posts

Top Posters:

DrRetard - 18

kofman - 14

tstyron - 10

merticois - 6

Needsnaming - 2

Administrator: Booker | Moderators: Booker, merticois, DrRetard, Rekoob, MaDaBr14


© Simple:Press Forum - Version 3.1.4 (Build 357)